DVD Review: "Superman Batman: Public Enemies"
This came out in the summer of 2009 -- I got a chance to view it this week.
The character designs are patterned off of Ed McGuiness' art style. I applaud the idea of wanting the characters to look like they did in the "Public Enemies" comic story.
However, McGuiness' style is primarily based on Capcom's house style. Compare his work to the character designs from the "Street Fighter II" series of video games and you will see the overwhelming influence. So the character designs in this animation look like a copy of a copy, and are awkward in many instances. The design team would have been better served by looking over Capcom's art and using that as their style base.
The color design used on the character faces was a poor choice. It looks like a shadow in a starburst pattern. Rather than giving depth to the form, it looks as if a sharp object has cast a shadow. Definitely something that should have been corrected in pre-production.
A Producer at Warner Bros. Animation should have made the decision to use designs from the animated "Superman" show, the second "Batman" animated show or even the animated "Justice League" show. If not the exact approved designs, then at least ones heavily inspired by them. The straights and curves of that style works elegantly in animation and it suits these characters in their cartoon format. The backgrounds and prop designs looked great, and the character animation looked close to the animation quality created in the above mentioned TV shows.
A very good choice was made for the returning voice actors. Tim Daly as "Superman", Kevin Conroy as "Batman", CCH Pounder as "Amanda Waller" and Clancy Brown as "Lex Luthor". This was great, all the right voices from the WB Network incarnation of the "Superman", "Batman" and "Batman Beyond" animated TV shows -- also used on Cartoon Network's animated "Justice League" series, not counting Superman.
For me, it felt right to hear those voices for those characters. In part, it is what I have become accustomed to. Having my high expectations met made me feel gratified. Some of the other Warner Bros. Direct-to-DVD cartoon movies have used a voice cast that I did not enjoy.
Of course, the "right" voices NOT matching the "right" model or look of the characters took a while for me to get used to. It did happen, but it was near the end of movie. Note that's a long time to watch a movie and continuously think, "they don't look right".
Story-wise, it moved at a good pace. There definitely was some filler that looked as if it was done just to get more characters in the movie. Overall, the dialogue worked, but there are some quirky moments when they use PG-13 cussing. Nothing is gained from those instances; most especially not earned is any sense of maturity. I would have chosen to stay PG on the dialogue. For example, a TV Host says something to the effect of, "stick it up your ass." It might have been funny if "up" and "ass" weren't bleeped out.
Clancy Brown's voice gives Luthor the presence of Yul Brenner and due to that, the threat of his actions seem credible and menacing. I am supposing this continuity does not tie into that of the "Justice League" or "Batman Beyond" as Braniac was not featured.
Am I glad I saw it... yeah.
Would I pay to own it... no.
Direction / Storyboards: 4 stars
Story / Plot / Dialogue: 1 stars
Background Design: 4 stars
Character Design: 1 star
Prop Design: 4 stars
Color Design: 1 star
Animation: 3 stars
Acting: 4 stars
Final Rating: 2.75 out of 5 stars.